James 4:11-12 | Judging
Last week James asked, "What causes quarrels and what causes fights among you?" and pointed us away from them and toward the passions at war within each of us. He showed us the pathway of repentance to be walked in seasons of relational conflict in the church: submit to God, draw near to Him, and humble ourselves before the Lord, because He gives more grace. But James knows that as a door of outward conflict closes, it often stays cracked open individually, and through that opening slithers one last remnant of conflict: the tendency to speak ill of those we are or have been at odds with. This week, James gets personal. "Do not speak evil against one another, brothers." In a social media age of soundbite cancel culture, slander can feel like second nature. Even in the church, our justifications get more refined: it's okay because it's true, because I only typed it, because I just wanted you to pray for it. Yet no matter how evil is wielded, James reminds us, it is still evil. Why? Not because it hurts feelings or makes us look like a jerk, but because when we speak against a brother or sister, we climb into a seat that belongs to God alone, judging not just a person but God's eternal law. Does that mean we should never speak into another believer's life? Not at all. James is talking about condemnation, not evaluation, and the same Scripture that forbids slander calls us to accountability, starting with the log in our own eye. There is only one lawgiver and judge, and He is the One who was destroyed in the flesh so that we might be saved. Join us as we look at what it means to show mercy, not judgment: to stop talking down to others and come down to meet their needs.
Good morning. It is wonderful to be with you as we open God's Word together. I invite you to open to James chapter 4, verses 11 through 12. We are continuing in our walk together through James's letter, and throughout, James has highlighted the inseparable link between our inner and outer person. He's noted that who we are inwardly is displayed by what we do outwardly.
Specifically, if we claim to be in Christ, trusting and following Jesus according to God's expressed word and his will and his way, then our lives should reflect that reality. We should be different from the world. Christ in us should be noticeably identifiable through our actions, through the way we live, the words we say, and the ways in which we say them. So to this effect, James said in chapter 1, verse 19, "Be quick to hear, slow to speak, slow to anger." In chapter 3, verse 6, James warned, "The tongue is a fire, a world of unrighteousness."
In chapter 4, verse 1, James addressed selfishness that causes quarrels and fights amongst believers in the church. So James has illuminated the fact that the natural man within us is quick to speak, often from a place of hasty anger, sending flaming arrows from the tongue meant to injure, demean, or humiliate even those who are to be loved and cared for by us.
Our natural man is selfish. Our natural man is jealous for his own glory.
Our natural man is self-exalting.
Yet, James reminds, our renewed man in Christ is none of those things. As one scholar wrote, the new birth of which James has already spoken makes us first fruits of his creation, but also brings us into the Father's birth family. Here is all the motivation we need to bless each other and speak well of each other. We have the same Father because we have the same Savior and the same Spirit. We have been brought to see our sinfulness and have mourned over it, and God has shown us more grace.
To speak ill of each other would be utterly contrary to the renewed nature we share in Christ.
So as we have read, a renewed nature in Christ should be marked by humility, grace, submission to God, a love and a desire to do what is right, an ongoing repentance and mourning over our sin, which then draws us toward the eternal joy of forgiveness and restoration that we have in Christ.
Rather than seeking to exalt ourselves, we should, as James said in chapter 4, verse 10, "Humble yourselves before the Lord, and he will exalt you."
Now, last week James showed us the pathway of repentance to be walked in seasons of relational conflict with one another in the church. Yet James knows that often as a door of outward conflict closes relationally, it often stays cracked open individually. And through this opening tends to slither one last vestige, or a remnant, of conflict that stokes the ongoing passions at war within us just when the coals are beginning to cool.
James knows there is a tendency, even amongst believers, to speak ill against those whom we are or have been in conflict with.
So in today's passage, James illuminates the fact that when we speak poorly about another brother or sister in Christ, what we are doing is uncovering not the depravity in another person, as is often our aim, but ultimately we are displaying a wickedness within ourselves.
A slanderous tongue reveals a judgmental heart. Yet, as James reminds, the throne of judgment has not been given for us to occupy. So let's read James chapter 4, beginning in verse 11. James says, "Do not speak evil against one another, brothers. The one who speaks against a brother or judges his brother speaks evil against the law and judges the law. But if you judge the law, you are not a doer of the law, but a judge. There is only one lawgiver and judge, he who is able to save and to destroy. But who are you to judge your neighbor?"
Now, in today's social media age and soundbite cancel culture, it's easy to become so accustomed to slanderous words that we grow a certain callousness towards them. They so readily surround us that they become almost expected, second nature, predictably present, and therefore not something that we hold as significant in our sights.
The comment sections on virtually any YouTube video or social media post or news headline are absolute cesspools of vitriol, pointed at people who have never met and likely will never meet.
So it's not a strong revelation to expose the fact that we, as human beings, have a natural bent towards speaking evil against one another. Now, what is, or at least should be, shocking, however, is that we are not immune to this poison, even in the church.
In the church, however, rather than blasting rhetoric broadly for explosive impact, we often employ weapons that create much slower or more subtle bleeds.
We may engage in gossip, taking a story, even one that is true, where it should not go and does not belong.
We may engage in embellishment, adding falsehood to an already uncomfortable truth to make it seem even more unthinkable.
We may simply use a tone of voice or a roll of the eyes or even a surgical silence toward brothers and sisters in Christ, all the while justifying our actions because at least we aren't doing so in the way the world does, right? No, our justifications are much more refined, right? Well, it's okay that I said it because it's true. Or it's okay that I said it to you because I already said it to their face. Or it's okay that I said it because I only said it behind their back.
Or even, well, I only typed it. I didn't say it. Or even, it's okay that I did because, hey, I just wanted you to pray for it.
Yet James reminds, no matter how evil is wielded, in the end it is still evil. Look at verse 11. He says, "Do not speak evil against one another, brothers." Now, this phrase "speak evil against" in the Greek is fairly broad. It means to speak in opposition to, or down to, or even against one another.
It's speaking with the goal or intent of attacking another person's character or reputation. It's a phrase that is often translated as slander. Now, the Bible denounces the sin of slander, or speaking evil against someone, more than any other sin.
Leviticus 19:16: "You shall not go around as a slanderer among your people." Psalm 101:5: "Whoever slanders his neighbor secretly I will destroy." Psalm 140:11: "Let not the slanderer be established in the land." Proverbs 20:19: "Whoever goes about slandering reveals secrets; therefore do not associate with them."
In Matthew 15:19, Jesus said slander comes from an evil heart and defiles a person. In 2 Corinthians 12:20, Ephesians 4:31, and Colossians 3:8, the apostle Paul warns his readers strongly against gossip, slander, malice, and other such forms of speech. Proverbs 11:9 says speaking evil against someone can actually destroy them. Then Proverbs 10:18 says summarily, "Whoever utters slander is a fool."
And that's just the tip of the iceberg. The word devil in the Greek, diabolos, means literally "false accuser" or "slanderer." Satan himself is defined by his accusations and his slander against God's people. That's why James is justified when he says slander, or speaking against a brother or sister in Christ, is indeed evil.
Now, why is it evil? We might expect James to say, because it's just not nice.
It hurts people's feelings, or when you do so, it makes you look like a jerk.
And while yes, all these things are true, it's not the relational or even the personal fallout that James addresses, but a much greater, or higher, injury. He continues in verse 11, "The one who speaks against a brother or judges his brother speaks evil against the law and judges the law. But if you judge the law, you are not a doer of the law, but a judge." So James says, above all, when we speak evil against a brother or sister in Christ, we are acting as a judge over them. Yet what we are actually judging, or putting under our microscope of self-superiority, is not just a person, but God's eternal law.
How does James make this connection? Well, the law comprised God's specific ordinances, rules, and instructions given to govern the moral, sacrificial, and sacred civil practices of God's chosen people, the Israelites. In the Old Testament, it was the expressed word, will, and way of God for his people. Now, while this side of the cross those sacrificial and even civil laws are no longer binding on God's people, the moral law and the spirit of the sacrificial and civil laws remain. This is why Jesus said in Matthew 5:17, "Do not think that I've come to abolish the law or the prophets. I've not come to abolish them, but to fulfill them." And when asked which was the greatest commandment, in summary of the law, Jesus said in Matthew 22:37-40, "You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind. This is the great and first commandment. And a second is like it: You shall love your neighbor as yourself. On these two commandments depend all the law and the prophets."
So in essence, Jesus said the entire spirit, focus, and purpose of God's law can be summed up as this: love God with everything you are, and love others as you yourself would want to be loved. So the issue James identifies, then, is that speaking evil or slander against a brother or sister is neither loving God nor treating others as we desire to be treated. We are acting in opposition to God's law because, one, when we put ourselves in the judgment seat over another, or speak to or about them as though they are beneath us, we are attempting to exercise a position of elevated authority alongside, in the place of, or even over the God who alone sits on the judgment seat over his people and his Word.
Now, this does not honor God, does not glorify God or love God. Rather, it demeans his sovereign authority as the one true king.
God alone is the Creator, the author of time, space, and history. God alone is the decider of what is good, right, and true. God alone is the authority to whom all creation is accountable. Therefore, God alone can be, and is, the rightful judge.
So God does not need us to crawl up into his chair and call balls and strikes for him. He is fully capable.
Slander against God's people does not express love for God. But second, when we judge, slander, or speak evil against a brother or sister in Christ, we are not loving them in the same way that Christ has loved us.
When we place judgment upon or slander a brother or sister, we are acting as if we are not under the law as they are, but over the law as only God is. And we forget that we too are nothing more than sinners, saved by grace through faith according to the sovereign will of a holy, merciful God. And we forget that the same grace and mercy extended to us in Christ is the same grace and mercy extended to them. And we forget the same sin nature that they are struggling to put to death is the same sin nature we wrestle with as well.
So when we demean or speak evil against another, it's as if we are saying, good grief, God, would you look at them? Can you believe how unrighteous they are? Can you believe how much they don't understand? They're not seeking for you, God. Look, they've turned aside.
They're worthless. They're not doing any good. What are we going to do about them?
To which God replies, Romans 3:10: "None is righteous. No, not one. No one understands. No one seeks for God. All have turned aside. Together they have become worthless. No one does good, not even one," including you.
God's Word says every one of us comes before God as guilty, broken sinners. Now, we may sin differently, but our status before God is the same. Therefore, our role is not to judge our neighbor, but to love our neighbor as God in Christ has loved us. And when we fail to love our neighbors, especially our brothers and sisters in Christ, we are saying that while we recognize God's law, we don't think we have to abide by it by loving others in that way, that we somehow are an exception in so doing. We, in effect, then stand in judgment over God's law.
Yet, as James says, if you judge the law, you are not behaving like a doer of the law, or someone under the law. You are acting like a judge, as someone who is over the law. Thus, James lovingly corrects us. He says, hey, we are not God. We are not the judge.
And therefore, James says, we should not judge.
Now, this is an aside, but I believe an incredibly significant and relevant one given today's passage.
Does James's assertion mean that we should never exercise any judgment about another person?
And the answer to that, according to the full counsel of Scripture, is no. That is not what James is saying, especially when it comes to the local church. Let me explain. The word judge, or judges, here in verse 11 in the Greek does not refer to judgment by means of evaluation, but judgment by means of condemnation. Say, well, what's the difference? Well, James is saying that it is not our role or our place to condemn another person for their sins, but biblically it is always our place to evaluate, even speak to the fruit that is proceeding from another brother or sister's life, even identifying it as sinful.
Scripture directs professing believers in Christ to co-evaluate the fruit that our lives produce for the purposes of encouragement, admonition, accountability, even our mutual protection in the church.
First Corinthians 5:13 says, "Is it not those inside the church whom you are to judge?" Second Timothy 3:16 says all Scripture is useful for and by the church for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness. In Matthew 7:15, Jesus said, "Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep's clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves." He also said in Matthew 18:15-17, "If your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you've gained your brother. But if he does not listen, take one or two others along with you, that every charge may be established by the evidence of two or three witnesses. If you refuse to listen to them, tell it to the church. And if he refuses to listen even to the church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector."
So biblically, we in the church are to continually consider the fruit of our own lives and the fruit of others' lives who claim to be in Christ along with us. It's how we know what to teach. It's how we reprove and correct and train and identify one another according to God's Word.
We cannot care for one another spiritually by ignoring one another's spirituality. And we cannot love one another intimately if we are not involved intimately in one another's lives.
Now, certainly there are some healthy boundaries to be applied there, but as James is highlighting, we are not judge, jury, and executioner over one another. God is judge, jury, and executioner over all of us. Our responsibility, then, is to help one another prepare to stand before his judgment, not endure unto ours.
Biblically, we are called as members of the same body to help one another trust and follow Jesus together well. Thus, we should invite, seek, and desire accountability in our lives as members of one body. Yet the Bible says we must start with ourselves first, as we have read this morning and here from Matthew 7:3: "Why do you seek the speck that is in your brother's eye, but do not notice the log that is in your own eye? Or how can you say to your brother, 'Let me take the speck out of your eye,' when there's a log in your own eye, you hypocrite, first take the log out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother's eye." Now, Jesus doesn't say here that we should completely avoid the speck in our brother's eye.
He says clearly that we should help them take it out. But we must come from a posture of humility, self-examination first, recognizing that our position under God, under his Word, and under his law is the same as theirs, that we are both sinners who sin. We both have need for our Savior. We both have need for one another.
And from that place, humbly, cautiously, methodically, when we recognize sin in one another, giving the benefit of the doubt, we should apply Matthew 18 by directly holding one another accountable for correction according to God's Word. This is one purpose, function, and responsibility of meaningful membership in the local church.
But again, we do so not because we have superiority over a brother or sister in Christ. We do so because we have a common accountability with them. In verse 12, James says, "There is only one lawgiver and judge, he who is able to save and to destroy. But who are you to judge your neighbor?"
James reminds us, there is only one lawgiver who is also the judge of those under his law, and as an exercise of his judgment, what does the lawgiver do?
Well, James says he is able to destroy, which is completely righteous and just, according to his authoritative decree over those who have rebelled against him and his kingdom. Yet James says this Lawgiver, this Judge, is also able to save.
Though all are guilty before the Judge, many will be saved by him. This is according to the sovereign decree of God the Father and the sacrificial work of Jesus Christ on the cross in our place. Philippians 2, beginning in verse 6, says, "Jesus, who, though he was in the form of God, did not count equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied himself, by taking the form of a servant, being born in the likeness of men. And being found in human form, he humbled himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross. Therefore God has highly exalted him and bestowed on him the name that is above every name, so that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father."
Now, if this was the posture of God toward us when we were dead in our trespasses and our sins against him, then James says, who are you to judge your neighbor? Who are you to assume a more prestigious place, position, and posture than your Lord?
God alone is the one true Judge over all, who is able to save and to destroy.
And because of his love, even for broken sinners like you and like me, our Judge sent God the Son to be destroyed in the flesh through his willing sacrificial death, that we might be saved by him to walk together in resurrected life, bearing good fruit for his glory and for our good.
Hebrews 7:25 says, "He, Jesus, is able also to save forever those who draw near to God through him, since he always lives to make intercession for them."
So, church, if Jesus Christ even now is making intercession for his people, then who are we to speak evil against them? And if Jesus Christ is the one who mediates for his people, then who are we to judge them?
As one scholar said, without his mercy we would all suffer condemnation because of Christ's work. He is willing to save and not destroy. Since we have received mercy, not judgment, we should show mercy, not judgment. We should not talk down to others. We should come down to meet their needs.
And if there is a need, we should meet it, not broadcast it. Amen. May it be done so among us for God's glory, according to his Word. Let's pray.
God, we do want to come to you this morning, humbly recognizing that we are all, every single one of us, by nature, set against you, wanting to build our own kingdoms, satisfy our own desires, our hearts, our mind, and our flesh.
But God, you have called us to something so much higher, so much more beautiful and true. That is to surrender to you and to come into alignment with your kingdom. And we can only do this by laying down our lives sacrificially at your feet, giving ourselves to you. And so, God, help us as we do so daily, weekly, monthly, for the rest of our lives. Help us not to think ill of those who come alongside us to do the same.
Help us not to speak poorly. Help us to encourage. Help us to lock arms, give an arm around a shoulder and the hand behind the back to encourage one another forward, as we so often ourselves need encouragement.
God, I thank you for your Word that boldly confronts us. I thank you for the encouragement of the love and the fellowship that we experience in this body. And I pray, God, that you would give us an even further love and further unity with one another, that we would glory in the gospel together.
God, we love you, and we thank you. We thank you for your Word. It's in the strong name of Jesus Christ. I pray.
